Why do White Evangelicals prefer Trump when they have Better Options?

Politics, Uncategorized 3 Minutes

Why do White Evangelicals Prefer Trump when they Have Better Options?

In the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections, approximately 80% of white evangelicals voted for Trump. Since then, they have remained some of Trump’s strongest supporters. This is somewhat strange, because his life runs contrary to evangelicals’ most cherished virtues. This must be unpacked a bit. Evangelicals are a subsection of Protestant Christianity which claim that their lives are guided by Biblical principles. Although this is somewhat true at an individual level (honest, hard-working, dedicated to their family, etc.), this is not accurate at a political level. Numerous surveys reveal that fewer than 15% of evangelicals have their political positions shaped by Scripture on important issues of our day (immigration, foreign policy, environment, health care, etc.). Their most important political concern has been to reduce the number of abortions taking place. Since Reagan, Republican presidential candidates have promised to re-shape the Supreme Court with enough conservative justices to overturn Roe v. Wade. During his presidency, Trump appointed three conservative justices to the Court, and as a result, Roe was overturned, and the legal status of abortion has been returned to the states.

Although Trump lost the 2020 election, he is running again and is way ahead of his Republican rivals: Nikki Haley, Ron DeSantis, Chris Christie and Vivek Ramaswamy. My question for white evangelicals is the following: Why do you continue to support Trump when his lifestyle runs contrary to core Christian values and you have better options? Here is a small sample of his character flaws.

  1. Trump is a racist. He began his campaign in 2015 by declaring that Mexicans were drug pushers, criminals, and rapists. In 2018 he called African countries, plus Haiti and El Salvador “shithole” countries.
  2. Trump is a womanizer and treats women as objects. In his Access Hollywood tape, Trump affirmed “And when you’re a star, they let you do it. You can do anything. … Grab ’em by the pussy. You can do anything.”
  3. He is a bully. In his rallies, he demeans others based on their physical handicaps, their looks, etc. instead of using reasonable, logical arguments.
  4. He is a compulsive liar. On the day of his inauguration, he lied about the size of the crowd, then told hundreds of significant lies during his presidency, including the allegation that he won the 2020 election. You can google “Trump and lies” for a long list with evidence.
  5. He is narcissistic. His demands for “loyalty” required people to violate the Constitution and their conscience. For those who violated their religious convictions, they have brought shame and disrepute to their faith.
  6. His vanity has led him to make false predictions. He predicted that under his leadership, Republicans would win so many elections, they would “get tired of winning”. That turned out to be false. Republicans lost the 2018 midterm election, the 2020 presidential election, and the special election in Georgia. They underperformed in 2022. Republicans are, in fact, tired of losing with Trump.
  7. His many crimes have led him to be charged with 91 counts in federal courts. It is likely that he will be found guilty of some felonies by the time of the election in November, 2024.

I know people who refuse to acknowledge any of these defects. This was understandable during the heat of the 2016 and 2020 elections, but is totally unreasonable today. There are better options: Haley, DeSantis, and Christie. They are fallen human beings (just like me). They have their own defects (just like me). They probably have skeletons in their closets (just like me). I have significant disagreements with each of them and some of their policies. Nevertheless, they all have been governors and have experience in constitutional positions of leadership. Each of them has a basic minimum integrity as public servants. Each of them would be a better option than Trump.

For further reading, I suggest the new book by Tim Alberta: The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory. American Evangelicals in an Age of Extremism.

Unknown's avatar

Published by lindyscott99

Published

12 thoughts on “Why do White Evangelicals prefer Trump when they have Better Options?”

  4. Lindy, you have stated my same questions far better than I could. And what bothers me most is feeling that a 2 party system is important for a healthy democracy, assuming both sides talk to each other, and that Trump will seriously harm that democracy if given the office 4 more years. But it is my opinion that he will not be elected, and that Nikki Haley could be elected if nominated, and Trump is taking away that option for many moderate Republicans who want to see a moderate government where both sides work together for the good of America, while not caving in to the far right or the far left.

    Like

    Reply

  5. Thanks, Lindy, for a concise summary of the challenges to our world presented by the former president’s sustained political popularity. It is especially disturbing to see this support being sustained within some elements of our Christian communities.

    I agree that your reference to read Tim Alberta’s work is valuable for understanding. Interestingly, your comments also align with those of David W. Baker in his 2006 commentary on the Book of Obadiah (The NIV Application Commentary: Joel, Obadiah, Malachi, 2006, Zondervan). Baker applies the prophecy of Obadiah to that of the church and politics in the early 2000s. Conditions have deteriorated since then.

    I found Baker’s admonition that “there are actions expected of rulers that are either right or wrong” … but “while society at large might question this, Christians cannot do so” (p. 176).

    Baker concludes his commentary on Obadiah, verses 8 and 9, like this:
    “…the fact that neither today’s society nor the church seems to be bothered about the loss of both moral vision and the ability to accomplish good in leading society is even more of a concern. We could well be looking back on the realization of an event like Obadiah’s prophecy. Where are today’s leaders who will base decisions on integrity rather than on either pragmatism or politics?” (p. 177).

    Pray that wisdom prevails, and that Baker’s question is well addressed.

    Like

    Reply

  6. Lindy,
    I have never voted for Trump for many of the reasons you so excellently laid out. In 2016 I was very surprised that anyone would vote for him in the Republican primaries since there were so many who were more worthy than him. I think the mistake that a lot of votes make is they thing about some one’s electability rather than their integrity. In the Spring of 2016 when voters saw that Trump had a path to the White House they ignored that He was not White House Worthy. In his 4 years as President instead of changing and showing a new found integrity, he actually got worse and was a lot worse President than I imagined he could be. When Co-vid came, he again had the opportunity to redeem himself and clean his image through the crucible of crisis. He did not change, in fact he was even worse. When he lost the election, he had the opportunity to be gracious in defeat and accept the mandate of the people. Instead of graciousness we received arrogance and insurrection.

    Dave Roller

    Like

    Reply

      1. I like Haley a lot. I lived in Columbia, S.C. for a few years before I got married and moved back to Chicago area. This was long before she was governor there, but I have kept an eye on her career and feel like she would be good.

        Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.