My father would frequently repeat this quote to me, “Figures never lie… but liars do figure”. During my many decades of life, I have found that this phrase quite accurately describes human nature. In fact, it is logical. We usually try to defend our actions with reasons that we hope are persuasive (if not persuasive to others, at least to ourselves). Sometimes these arguments are valid, but at other times they are illogical rationalizations.
What we do on a personal level also occurs in the broader society. In healthy societies, opposing or alternative points of view are defended and debated in the public arena. These arguments frequently use statistics. Citizens need to think hard to evaluate the merits of the various arguments. In times of deep polarization, like our current situation, we must avoid knee/jerk reactions if we want to reach the truth. How do we evaluate these competing points of view when they involve figures, percentages, and statistics? I have found the following questions quite helpful.
- Are the figures accurate?
- What do these figures reveal (the merits and purposes of the argument)?
- What do these figures omit or hide (the flaws of the argument)?
The Covid-19 pandemic is a good case study, because statistics play such an important role in the national debate. For example, President Trump has often stated, “We do more Covid-19 testing than any other country.” At one level, this is a true statement. Because the United States is a large nation with a sizeable population (roughly 330 million people), the total number of tests administered here (about 40 million tests) is larger than any other country. The intention of the statement is to create confidence in the government, that our political leaders are adequately managing the pandemic, and that the large number of infections is to be expected.
At a more important level, this statement is quite false and misleading. We should compare the percentage of people who have been tested with the total population, in other words, “per capita”. We could then compare “apples with apples”. At a per capita level, the United States is testing for Covid-19 at about the middle of the pack of industrialized nations. Depending on the exact date of comparison, the U.S. has tested more per capita than France, Japan and Sweden, but fewer than Australia, Russia, and Spain. The purpose of this misleading information is to paint a more positive picture of our government leadership than is warranted.
In light of this frequent misuse of numbers and statistics, what should we expect of each other? I hope that fair minded people will treat the figures accurately and not jump to inaccurate conclusions. Both those who support and those who oppose Trump (or any other leader or policy) should be honest enough to acknowledge all valid and pertinent figures and statistics, in other words, to find common ground. I also expect that people of all sides of an issue would disavow figures that are obviously wrong. We must hold each other and our leaders to the high standard of truth-telling.
We are living in difficult times. The Covid pandemic is just one of our many challenges. If we want to overcome these problems, we must treat each other with serious respect, affirming what is true, rejecting what is not.
 Other more useful criteria would be per capita measurements of hospitalizations, ICU usage, and mortality rates.
 The president has made claims that are clearly false such as “We test for Covid-19 more than all other countries combined” and, more recently, “99% of Covid cases are totally harmless”. His supporters should have the courage to reject and distance themselves from these outlandish affirmations.
4 thoughts on “Figures Never Lie… but Liars do Figure”
And on the other hand the Democrats should disregard the 4 years of lies from their leaders also. And Joe Biden. And “Mad Maxine, Pelosi. Schumer, Nadler, Schiff and the Coumo brothers also. Let alone CNN and MSNBC. We’ll even throw the FBI in that mix also. That’s the one constant truth about politics. The last one in smells just as bad as the first one out. Good to hear from you Lindy. Hope you’re enjoying retirement. I’ve got two years to go, God willin’. But first I have some surgery I have to live thru then God willin’ I’ll take it from there. Be firm, fly low and stay cool mi amigo.
Hi Paul, We must have a healthy suspicion of political affirmations, whether they come from the left, the right of down the middle. We must be careful not to let our ideological commitments distort our handling of fact and figures.
Lindy, did you see Dr. Scott Gottlieb’s presentation on Face the Nation this past Sunday? It starts at 20:37 and stops at 29:14 if you google Face the Nation July 5th. You wrote a very good article. Dr. Gottlieb’s presentation supports what you stated in your article and clarified a number of the points for me that you brought up.
Thanks for your note. We must be persistent in a rigorous use of facts and figures, especially in life and death situations like Covid-19.